This is in one post on the black woman who became a rabbi.

In reference to a conservative convert “Someone wants something, wants it real bad but doesn’t actually want to make a 100% commitment to it.” – huh what does that have to do with anything.

“A fascinating subject which I often wonder about. However, I believe that Rabbi Hecht is treading dangerously close to trouble by implying that somehow the non-halachic (i.e. non-religious/orthodox) streams of Judaism are somehow on an equal footing as Halachic Judaism. As much as we yearn for their return to the fold, it behooves us to keep a great distance from them in most matters to prevent granting them legitimacy.”

And how are they not on equal footing unless you have a very particularistic view of the world. If you identify yourself as Orthodox you are valid and “religious”?

Why would I convert into “orthodox” way of Judaism? There has not been one convincing argument. The closest I get is that it is more apt to keep tradition.

And I’m honored that blog midrash was a place where people could help you feel the fun in the wrestle.

I think it’s important to remember that the Shammai that you speak of (and I’m not sure exactly who you are referring to) is a small minority, or so I believe. It’s amazing how loud a minority can be.

Kol tuv.

On Saturday at 10 AM I will be chanting Torah for the first time. I am excited.

Very intelligent piece! I think basically, you’ve hit the nail on the head. I’ve seen people like this do very hateful things in various communities and no one stood up to them. Well I did, but then again, I was from “Hillel” so I didn’t count…;-) Keep writing and chag sameach.